Skip to content
Techtember

Always First. Fast Tech News.

Smartphones in use, illustrating the fight over teen social feeds.
Image: Anna Barclay / Getty Images via TechCrunch

Opinion

Opinion: Meta, Google and TikTok Are Right That California's Teen Law Forces More Surveillance. That Does Not Make Autoplay Untouchable.

The three platforms sued to block AB 1709. Age checks that scoop data from every user are a real cost. Personalized feeds for 15-year-olds are still a design choice, not sacred speech.

Los Angeles · Marcus Reid, Opinion · Nov 6 2026

LOS ANGELES - Meta, Google and TikTok each sued California Attorney General Rob Bonta on Thursday to stop AB 1709, the law that bans autoplay and personalized feeds for users under 16 and can force platforms to delete accounts that keep those features on. The fines run as high as $50,000 per affected minor. Governor Gavin Newsom signed the bill in September. It takes effect at the start of next year.

Screenshot: TechCrunch coverage of the Meta, Google and TikTok lawsuits, Nov. 5, 2026 Screenshot: TechCrunch

The companies’ First Amendment and Section 230 arguments were easy to predict. Meta says the Act would make it “unlawful for Meta to disseminate speech to minors altogether” unless it changes how feeds and autoplay work. A TikTok spokesperson called the law “a blatantly unconstitutional restriction on free expression” that hits the same preference-based curation bookstores and streaming services use. Google says parents already have controls, that YouTube autoplay is off by default for minors, and that “overly broad laws like this actually break the systems we’ve built to help kids find high-quality, age-appropriate videos.”

They have one strong point that deserves more airtime than the free-speech framing. Age-gated design laws almost always push platforms toward more identity checks. The Electronic Frontier Foundation’s Rindala Alajaji put it plainly in a briefing quoted by TechCrunch: AB 1709 “compels platforms to collect even more information from every user, invading everyone’s privacy and frustrating our ability to remain anonymous online.” That is not a straw man. Australia’s under-16 social media ban is already teaching the industry how much age assurance costs in data. A California rule that turns on account deletion for teens who leave autoplay on will pressure every large platform to know, with more certainty, who is 15 and who is 17.

TechCrunch’s report on the filings against Attorney General Rob Bonta. Image: TechCrunch

That privacy cost is real. It does not make personalized autoplay for a ninth grader a constitutional absolute. Infinite scroll, autoplay and recommendation ranking are product choices. California already told the industry, when Newsom signed the bill, that those choices look different when the user is a child. Meta’s own children’s-safety settlement track, which TechCrunch notes can run as high as $18 billion across 29 states, undercuts any claim that the status quo was working.

The useful fight is over means, not ends. If California wants fewer addictive defaults for teens, it should require clear parental tools, default-off autoplay and ranking modes that do not depend on building a harder identity file for every adult in the state. If the platforms want to win in court, they should spend less time wrapping feed ranking in the First Amendment and more time proposing age checks that do not turn the entire user base into a surveillance project.

Bonta’s office said it is reviewing the filings and will defend “commonsense laws to protect kids online.” The teenagers stuck between a blunt statute and three companies that monetize attention will not get a clean win from either side. They deserve a law that changes the product without making everyone prove their birthday to watch a video.